Study Compares Health Impacts of Meat and Plant-Based Alternatives

Researchers analyzed how a diet containing fundamental mar is compared to plant-based meat, especially in terms of cardiovascular health and diabetes. This study published in The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition looked at diets rich in plant-based food and found that they benefit heart and metabolic health due to their wide variety of health-promoting components like vitamins, fibers, and antioxidants. However, for those who regularly eat meat, switching to such diets can be challenging due to deep-seated cultural, historical, and social influences on meat consumption and socioeconomic factors. Plant-based meat analogs (PBMAs) are designed to mimic the taste and texture of real meat using sustainable ingredients and are becoming increasingly prevalent worldwide. 

This new research compared the effects of diets based on plant-based meat and transitional animal-based meat on the heart health of Singaporeans at a higher risk for type 2 diabetes. The main question was whether replacing animal meat with plant-based meat would improve heart health and reduce the risk of chronic diseases. This study involved 89 participants for eight weeks; half were told to eat plant-based meat, and the other half were given animal meat in their diet. The researchers looked at bad cholesterol levels, blood sugar, and blood pressure, among other health indicators. 

The findings showed no significant changes in cholesterol profiles for either diet, but both diets were linked to improvements in some blood sugar markers. One diet had no clear advantage over the other in improving heart health. However, in a smaller group that closely monitored their blood sugar, those eating animal meat managed their blood sugar levels better. 

Blood pressure improvements were also noted in the animal meat group but not in the group that consumed plant-based meat. This suggests that the benefits often associated with plant-based diets might not directly apply to people who consume plant-based meat, as they differ nutritionally from whole plant foods and their impact on heart health. 

Nutrient analysis shows that animal meat diets provide more protein, while plant-based meat is higher in sodium, potassium, and calcium. The better blood sugar control in the animal meat group might be due to their lower carb and higher protein intake. 

Even though the study did not look into protein absorption, other research suggests that proteins from plant based meat might not be as easily absorbed as those from animal meats, affecting insulin and gut hormone responses differently. 

Although plant-based meat diets are becoming a more popular protein choice, this study’s findings don’t support the idea that they offer better heart and metabolic health benefits than diets that include animal meats. 

Journal Reference: Author links open overlay panelDarel Wee Kiat Toh a, a, b, c, & AbstractBackgroundWith the growing popularity of plant-based meat analogs (PBMAs). (2024). Plant-based meat analogs (PBMAs) and their effects on cardiometabolic health: An 8-week randomized controlled trial comparing PBMAs with their corresponding animal-based foods.

Retrieved from https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0002916524003964